Now that my blog is getting more grown up, I should make a more sensible comments policy. I don’t provide a platform for every attention-seeking nutter out there. I welcome general comments, praise, criticisms, requests for clarifications and anything generally useful or reasonable. Most will still get published. I won’t publish some comments:
The comments are really thinly disguised ads;
a) The commenter obviously hasn’t shown me the courtesy of actually reading the entry they are supposedly commenting about’
b) The comments contain anything abusive, offensive, or illegal, such as racist comments, incitement to violence etc
c) Comments whose main line of argument is ‘I would do it that way and that would be stupid, therefore you are stupid’;
d) The proposal that is clearly stated as being designed for x won’t work well in y, therefore is rubbish (irate New York bicycle riders please take note, some of you fall foul of a, c and d)
e) Comments that insist on citations for every point of my argument. I can use Google, so can you. Ditto comments demanding massive research projects. Give me a lab with generous staff and funding and we can chat.
Please note that while I have time to reply sometimes, I can’t always respond. Also, my blog articles are not intended to be of professional journal quality (I write those directly for the professional journals). Often they are just to introduce an idea at a superficial level, so I don’t aim for completeness or list citations.