The Wall Street Journal carries an article on behalf of ‘climate scientists’ annoyed that some people don’t believe them any more. It asks ‘ do you consult your dentist about your heart condition?’ I think we’re supposed to answer ‘no’, and by extension, we should never believe anyone who isn’t an official ‘climate scientists’ about anything to do with climate.
Sorry, but I would happily answer ‘yes’ to their question under some circumstances, equivalent to those in today’s ‘climate science’. In some circumstances I would ask just about anyone with any medical knowledge except my heart doctor.
If for example:
he is totally ignoring the whopping great spike sticking out of my chest because no mention of it appears in any peer-reviewed heart journals, or
my heart doctor regularly deliberately ignores the truth, or
he often tries to mislead me, telling me what is sort of the truth but spins it in such a way that it says almost the opposite, or
the association of heart surgeons only accepted as members those who belong to a particular faith and did everything it could to prevent anyone else with any actual heart expertise from joining, or
my heart doctor doesn’t believe that the heart is involved in pumping blood, and argues forcefully instead that blood flow happens by some sort of magnetic effect and that as everyone with any heart expertise whatsoever knows, the heart is only the seat of the mind and emotions, and that only a bunch of ill-informed ‘non heart doctor’ consultants, GPs, physicians, and even some dentists, who are never published in the official Association of Heart Surgeons Journal think the heart has anything to do with blood flow, or
my dentist was honest and spent a great deal of his time researching heart disease on the side, or
or my heart surgeon is being paid to tell me a particular answer regardless of my actual condition,or
my heart doctor holds huge investments in the funeral industry, or
there were any one of a million other reasons why my dentist might give me more accurate and honest advice than my heart surgeon, then
yes I would. Then I would ask my dentist about my heart condition and ignore my heart doctor.